Officials of the state-run property insurer of last resort Friday
told their board of directors that the 10.5 percent average rate
increase approved in April may have to change. Steve Cottrell,
chief financial officer of Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance
Corp., told the Citizens board that as the new rates were being
programmed into the Citizens computer system, "we found data
anomalies" in the rate structures in two parishes and "eight
others looked a little funny to us."
Cottrell said the major factor was the cost of wind and hail
coverage in those areas and how they affected the overall rates.
"We want to be rock solid that e (the rates) make sense and are
the right thing to do," Cottrell said.
The two parishes where the problem cropped up are in southwest
Louisiana, said Citizens Chief Executive Officer Richard
Robertson. He said he did not know where the eight other
possible problem parishes are located.
Citizens officials did not disclose the names of the parishes.
Robertson said that "all of the rates are in question," so Citizens
will have to re-check the data to make certain there are no other
problems. The rates are scheduled to go into effect June 1 for
new and renewing policies.
Robertson said after all of the parishes are checked, "I suspect
(the rates adopted in April) will go down somewhat.… There
should be some movement downward."
Cottrell agreed that any changes based on a review of the wind
and hail coverage should result in lower rates.
Neither Citizens executive would estimate how much the rates could
change. The new rates will have to be resubmitted to the board and
reviewed again by actuaries on Insurance Commissioner Jim Donelon's
staff.
By law, Citizens can not have rates that are competitive with
the private market. Citizens has to charge at least 10 percent
more than the highest premiums in an area.
The rate review may delay the implementation of the new rates
by June 1, an angry Donelon told Cottrell at the meeting. "You
are delaying … something that the board has already
done and the law requires" by June 1.
Donelon told Cottrell he wants to meet with Citizens actuaries
and other officials as soon as possible.
By Ed Anderson,
The Times-Picayune, April 20, 2012
The legal maneuvering continues between Louisiana Citizens Property
Insurance Corp. and 18,500 policyholders involved in a class-action
lawsuit over claims adjustments from hurricanes Katrina and Rita.
In the latest round, Citizens asked a 19th Judicial District judge
to stop the insurer's bank, Regions Bank, from turning over
$104.6 million to the policyholders. Judge Timothy Kelly's order,
signed at 7 p.m. Thursday, temporarily prevented the East Baton
Rouge Sheriff's Office from taking the money under an order from
the 24th Judicial District Court.
Kelly also set an April 30 hearing for a permanent halt to the seizure.
The original judgment, issued three years ago in 24th Judicial District
Court, was $92.9 million, but legal interest is adding around $10,200
each day to the total.
Citizens attorney James Babst said the insurer is a "political
subdivision" of the state, and therefore its assets are exempt
from seizure.
Political subdivisions include school boards, sheriffs and any other
public or governmental bodies not considered a state agency.
Under the Louisiana Constitution, the governing bodies of political
subdivisions decide whether to pay legal judgments, Babst said.
Citizens' governing body is its board of directors.
More...